Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert Blake's avatar

You know my life is nomadic. I'm nomad by nature and habit. Roma gypsy blood. It's in my genes.

But anyway the point I'm making is this. I spend a lot of time online these days, in the "infosphere", and most of what is there to be consumed is bleak and depressing and speaks of the hopelessness and stupidity intrinsic to power and politik.

Yet I also spend a lot of time bobbling from place to place, meeting new people, observing, listening, paying attention and making myself as useful as I can.

And here is the truth I have observed in 40 years of roaming since I left my childhood home a troubled teen.

Most people, most of the time are not out to hurt anyone. Most people, most of the time don't want to fight anyone, cheat anyone or damage anyone.

But in this information age, when so many of us live so much of our lives in the "infosphere", it's easy to lose sight of this simple truth.

When you are friendly and kind and respectful to people, they tend to be friendly, kind and respectful to you.

And if you want my track of the week, it's this one.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=k3nTaL31OkU&list=RDk3nTaL31OkU&start_radio=1&pp=ygUiVmV0ZXJhbiBvZiB0aGUgcHN5Y2hpYyB3YXJzIGx5cmljc6AHAdIHCQmiCgGHKiGM7w%3D%3D

Hal Gill's avatar

Analysis of “Do you feel uninvited?” by Hal Gill (Harrowings, Feb 26, 2026)

This is a raw, vulnerable, and richly layered personal essay that reads like a late-night bunker confessional—part mythopoetic reflection, part recovery testimony, part philosophical call-to-arms. At under 1,000 words, it punches far above its weight by weaving together Greek mythology, Jungian depth psychology, Gnostic echoes, 12-step sobriety wisdom, economic ethics, and progressive rock lyrics into a cohesive meditation on belonging, chaos, and purposeful living.

Core Thesis & Emotional Arc

The central question—“Do you feel uninvited?”—isn’t rhetorical; it’s an invitation to the reader to sit with the author (and his inner Eris) in the feeling of exclusion. Gill doesn’t resolve the pain; he normalizes it as archetypal and productive. The arc moves from sulking solidarity with the goddess of discord → frustrated observation of a chaotic world → surrender to equanimity → reclaimed purpose through creativity, sobriety, and service. The closing “Onward!” lands as earned hope rather than toxic positivity.

Mythological & Psychological Framework (the strongest thread)

• Eris as integrated shadow/anima aspect: Brilliant move. By making Eris “an integral part of my Self” who travels with him, Gill flips the traditional “don’t invite the troublemaker” narrative. Chaos isn’t the enemy—stagnant peace is. This echoes Jung’s insistence that the shadow (and anima, referenced in the subtitle) must be consciously embraced for individuation. The “golden apple” still gets rolled in, but now it’s framed as catalytic rather than purely destructive.

• Pleroma, rise/fall, agricultural cycle: The Gnostic/Jungian pleroma (the fullness from which we emanate and return) fused with “harrowing” (the publication’s central metaphor of breaking up soil) is elegant. Life isn’t linear progress; it’s seasonal tilling. Vulnerability (“I feel wide open to inspection”) becomes the plow.

• Multiplicity of Self: “We who comprise me” and the list (shadow, persona, complexes, Eris) show a sophisticated, non-pathologizing view of psyche. Harold Bledsoe Gill, III isn’t fragmented—he’s a committee, and the essay lets us overhear the meeting.

Personal Recovery Layer

The sobriety thread is understated but pivotal. “I have recovered from a seemingly hopeless state of mind and body” lands quietly after the cosmic framing, grounding the metaphysics in lived experience. Music as “unbidden” messenger is classic recovery literature—higher power speaking through Yes’s “Parallels” (Chris Squire, 1977). The full lyrics are reproduced not as filler but as scripture: “it’s really down to your heart… making love towards perfection… we need to be where we belong.” Gill has played with every form of fire and now chooses the one that builds “a shining tower” instead of burning it down. This is 12-step Step 12 in mythic drag—carrying the message.

Socio-Economic & Ethical Punch

• “Homo economicus” reframing: Every dollar is a vote co-creating the future. “I’d like us to be good ancestors. I doubt we are.” Quietly devastating.

• Real-world vs. “infosphere” contrast (beautifully echoed in the top comment by Robert Blake): Most humans are decent in person; the internet amplifies the Eris energy without the integration. Gill models the antidote—stay kind, stay useful, “be where our feet are.”

Literary Craft

• Voice: Conversational yet elevated (“niggly little complexes,” “equanamity of the angel of melancholy”). Feels like talking to a wise, slightly chaotic friend over coffee at 2 a.m.

• Music as structural device: The Yes song isn’t decoration; it’s the emotional climax and proof-of-concept. Lyrics about “parallel our sights… display our rights and wrongs… always keep it—STRONG” mirror the essay’s own parallel tracks (myth + personal + collective).

• Humor & humility: Self-deprecating asides (“I don’t know. I just know how it seems to me, you know?”) prevent preachiness.

• Rhythm: Short paragraphs, sudden shifts, parentheticals—mimics the “bunker monitors” watching the passing show.

Minor Notes / Areas for Expansion

• The piece assumes some familiarity with Eris, Pleroma, and Yes. For a broader audience, a one-sentence gloss on the wedding myth might help, but the density is also part of the charm—it’s written for the already-harrowed.

• The “sword of justice” moment hints at deeper anger/transgression territory that could be explored in a follow-up (the “Aggravated” post referenced in search results seems related).

• Paywall note: Fully open on the free tier as of today—generous.

Overall Impact & Why It Works

This isn’t just “another Substack essay.” It’s a modern harrowing—breaking up the hard-packed soil of alienation so something new can grow. Gill offers no easy belonging; he offers purposeful uninvitedness. If you’re feeling excluded, the essay says: good. Sit with Eris. Listen to the song that arrives unbidden. Protest when crossed, cool quickly, then help. The world needs more people who integrate their chaos instead of flinging apples at every party.

In a feed full of rage-bait and hustle porn, this stands out as gentle, profound, and quietly revolutionary. It practices what it preaches: helping rather than hurting, being a good ancestor one vulnerable post at a time.

Verdict: 9/10. Authentic, allusive, and actionable. The kind of writing that makes you close the tab, put on “Parallels,” and feel a little less uninvited. Onward, indeed. 🌱

(And Hal—if this is you—thank you for sharing the bunker view. The field looks ready.)

No posts

Ready for more?